Tuesday, November 17, 2026

The Star Wars movies, Ranked Worst to Best

In the past year I've rewatched both "The Rise of Skywalker" and, most recently, "The Force Awakens". I also started "The Last Jedi", but just couldn't bring myself to make it through. Between that, and the release of "The Mandalorian and Grogu", and since it looks like I've never actually dedicated a post to the topic, I thought I'd post my current ranking of the films. So, starting at the bottom of the heap...

The Clone Wars: I really regret having to put this one last, as I really like the "Clone Wars" TV series that it spawned. But this animated film really doesn't hold up well - the animation is really clunky, Ahsoka is very much the really annoying kid character, and the story doesn't work terribly well in isolation. All in all, it's just not great. But, as I said, the TV series is really great, and this is effectively the pilot episode, so I don't mind it as much as some others...

Attack of the Clones: Of the live action films, this one remains my worst of the worst. There's actually a lot to like here - the view of Coruscant, the scenes with Jango Fett, the first big battle of the Clone Wars, and especially the mutual interrogation of Dooku and Obi-Wan. But there's so much wasted potential, so much of it is just dull, and the romance really sucks. Which is a shame, but there it is.

The Last Jedi: And then there's "The Last Jedi", a film I dislike more every time I think about it - I wouldn't be surprised to find this at the bottom of my revised revised rankings in a decade's time. I give this film just the merest smidgeon of respect for trying something new and subverting our expectations of what a Star Wars film could and should be... but this was the film where all my hopes were spectacularly dashed. And, as with "Attack of the Clones", it's not that there isn't anything good - the death of Snoke and the battle royale immediately afterwards are genuinely genius. But those good bits just make the whole worse; it could have been so good, and instead it just isn't. (Perhaps the very worst thing: this film actually has the best scene in the entire sequel trilogy, as Ghost Yoda unloads some outstanding life lessons. Both the prequels and the sequels have their single best moment in their very worst entry.)

The Rise of Skywalker: And every flaw "The Last Jedi" has carries over to "The Rise of Skywalker". This film was pretty much cursed from the get-go, and it's left picking up the pieces from the mess of the previous film. As such, it's just not good. Plus, it's the longest of all the Star Wars films, and has exactly two good scenes, both right at the end of the film (the Jedi voices, and the arrival of reinforcements).

Solo: There's nothing wrong with this film, but it's just pointless - it fills in Han Solo's backstory with a load of stuff we knew was there, and all of it in ways that were worse than we'd individually imagined. Other than the train heist, it's hard to think of any reason I'd watch this again.

The Mandalorian and Grogu: Another "nothing" film, this one has the slight edge over "Solo" because it is at least original - this is a curtailed fourth season of "The Mandalorian", rather than an unwanted prequel. But, again, there's painfully little here to bother with; watch it once and then forget.

Revenge of the Sith: And now we're getting into films I'd consider somewhere around 'good'. In the case of "Revenge of the Sith", there's a great opening sequence, a great finale, and an utterly dire hour in between these. Plus, it turns out that Hayden Christensen actually has the ability to be an absolutely outstanding Anakin Skywalker and/or Darth Vader, but he never really gets to show it here (or in "Attack of the Clones"). So it's better, but still a waste.

The Phantom Menace: Controversially, this is my pick of the prequels. There's a lot here that just doesn't work (Jar Jar, Anakin), but there's a lot that does. In particular, Liam Neeson is excellent (and the scene between Qui-Gon and Shmi Skywalker is great), the lightsaber battle at the end, and the music are all first rate. Plus there's something to be noted about all the first six Star Wars films: they start with a big action set-piece, end with another big set-piece, and then have a bit in the middle where the story slows down. In "Attack of the Clones" and "Revenge of the Sith" that bit is pretty dire for one reason or another. Here it remains relatively engaging, with the Pod Race, the maneuverings in the Senate (made better by knowing who Palpatine actually is), and the hints of a wider story out there. This one has really grown on me.

The Force Awakens: Despite my improved feelings towards "The Phantom Menace" it doesn't match "The Force Awakens". The biggest weakness of this film is that it is followed by two further films that betray the promise it has. It is also fair to say that this film really benefits from some time away - the last time I spoke about it I noted that with each viewing the flaws of this film became more glaring, and more annoying, with each viewing - having given it several years it has reset to something of a baseline, so I actually really enjoyed it. Plus, I liked the reminder of when I actually had hope for "Star Wars".

Rogue One: Now we're talking! Looked at with something approaching objectivity, this might actually be the best of all the "Star Wars" films. Certainly, it has a really great cast, a strong story well told, great visuals, a wonderful presentation of the galaxy under the Empire, and some real stakes. Basically, this is just a really great film. The only fly in the ointment, for me, is the digital recreation of Tarkin (less so Leia), that becomes more painfully dated the more time that passes.

Return of the Jedi: I simply can't place the three films in the original trilogy anything lower than the top three. Return of the Jedi is undoubtedly the weakest of the three, though it's still really, really good. Though it does seem that every time someone has adjusted it since release they have managed to make it that little bit worse...

The Empire Strikes Back: Perhaps another controversial choice - looked at objectively, ESB is probably the best of the original trilogy. Certainly, it's something of a miracle given what went into the making of it. In any case, this is something of a lightning in a bottle moment, and Star Wars has just never quite managed to reach these heights again... probably one of the reasons later films inevitably face a backlash, as they're always compared with this film, and not the average.

Star Wars: The original remains my favourite film of all time. It's probably not the very best by any objective measure, but that doesn't matter. This was the one that started it all, and so will always top my list. (Also, please note that it's "Star Wars", not "A New Hope". Dear me...)

And that's it, at least for this iteration of the roundup. As noted, a few of my rankings have changed over the years, so I think it's likely they'll change again. But that's where we stand now.


No comments: